Key action: the decision that matters most
The action is the single most important thing about a digital piano, more than the brand, the voice count or any clever feature. It is what the keys feel like under your fingers, and it is what builds, or fails to build, proper technique. Insist on a fully weighted hammer action across all 88 keys. A weighted action uses real hammers to recreate the resistance of an acoustic piano, so the keys push back when you press them, and that resistance is what teaches the finger strength and dynamic control a pianist needs. A semi-weighted or synth-action keyboard is cheaper and lighter, but it teaches the wrong touch and is a false economy for anyone serious about learning.
The best actions go one step further and are graded, meaning the bass keys are heavier to press than the treble keys, exactly as on a real grand. In our testing the Kawai ES120 and Roland FP-30X had the most convincing graded actions, with a settled, even response that rewarded careful playing. The Yamaha P-145 and Korg B2 use slightly more compact actions that are still genuinely weighted and perfectly good for learning, and the budget Alesis Recital Pro proves you can get a real hammer action for £279, though it is lighter and less even. Whatever your budget, the rule holds: spend your money on the action first. It is the part you feel within the first ten minutes and the part you cannot upgrade later.
Sound and polyphony: what to look for
A digital piano makes its sound from recordings, or models, of a real instrument, so the quality of that grand-piano voice is what you hear first. The big names all sample genuine acoustic grands: Yamaha its CFX, Roland its SuperNATURAL engine, Casio its Morphing AiR system and Kawai its Shigeru Kawai SK-EX. The differences are real but subtle, and in a quiet room the Roland and Kawai have the most three-dimensional tone. For most buyers, every piano we recommend has a grand voice good enough to enjoy daily; the cheaper Korg and Alesis are a step behind but still pleasant.
One spec is easy to overlook and worth understanding: polyphony, the maximum number of notes a piano can play at once before it cuts off the oldest ones. The sustain pedal and layered voices use it up quickly, so we treat 128 notes as a sensible minimum for anything beyond simple practice. To put numbers on it, the Roland FP-30X leads with 256-note polyphony, the Casio and Kawai offer 192, the Korg 120 and the Alesis 128, all comfortable. The Yamaha P-145's 64 is the lowest and the one figure to watch: it is fine for beginner repertoire but will cut notes on dense, heavily pedalled music. If you expect to progress quickly, choose 128 notes or more.
Speakers: why wattage matters
Unless you only ever play through headphones, the on-board speakers decide how the piano sounds in your room, and the spread is wide. Speaker power runs from 14 W on the Yamaha P-145 up to 40 W on the Kawai ES120, with the Korg B2's 30 W the standout value. As a rough guide, 14 to 16 W suits a bedroom or study up to about 16 m²; 22 W, as on the Roland, fills an average living room; and 30 to 40 W is what you want if the piano doubles as the main sound source in a large or open-plan room. Do not assume more is always better, though: in a small room a 14 W piano is perfectly full, and every model here lets you practise silently through a headphone socket regardless of its speaker power.
Features worth paying for, and ones you can skip
A few features genuinely matter. A sustain pedal is essential from the start, and most portable pianos include a basic one; a proper triple-pedal unit and a sturdy stand are worth adding once you are committed, because a wobbly table encourages poor posture. Bluetooth or USB connectivity to a learning app such as Smart Pianist or Roland Piano App turns a tablet into a guided teacher and is well worth having; only the Roland here offers Bluetooth audio for wireless music streaming, while the others connect by cable or Bluetooth MIDI. A headphone socket is non-negotiable for silent late-night practice, and thankfully every model has one.
Other features are nice-to-have rather than deciding factors. A long voice list looks impressive on the box, but for piano practice the single grand voice is the one that matters, so do not let a piano with 56 voices pull you away from one with a better action and 10. Battery power, as on the Casio PX-S1100, is a genuine bonus if you need to play away from a socket, but irrelevant if the piano lives in one spot. And brand buys you build quality, support and resale value, which is worth paying for, but never a substitute for the right action.